Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

Compare the pros Pros and cons of wireless and wired smart card readers from the customer customers point-of-view.

Umständliche Handhabung bei kabelgebundenem Einsatz im mobilen Bereich; wird in der Regel nicht akzeptiert.
Comparasion

Wired

WirelessComments

example

certgate AirID


Use Cases
For stationary use in the office with Windows (Desktops, Notebooks, Tablets)
Email signing and encryption, smartcard logon, web services etc.(tick)(tick)
For mobile use with Windows (Notebooks, Tablets)
Email signing and encryption, smartcard logon, web services etc.

(warning)

(restricted usability)

(tick)

Inconvenient handling when used with cables wired readers in mobile use. Is generally Generally not accepted.

Formobile use with Apple iOS (Smartphones, Tablets)
Email signing and encryption, smartcard logon, web services etc.

(error)

(tick)
For mobile use with Android (Smartphones, Tablets)
Email signing and encryption, smartcard logon, web services etc.
(error)(tick)
Contactless Use Cases
FollowMe printing, time recording, access control, payment etc.(error)(tick)
Identity Card
The ID card function is fully retained(error)(tick)
Usability
Multi-device use
(error)

(tick)

Only ONE reader required for ALL end user devices (Notebook, Tablet, Smartphne etc.).

Multiple users accounts on one device

(tick)

(tick)

For example, several users log on to a computer with his their cards.

Easy handling without any replugging

(error)

(tick)

No need to inserted insert and removed remove the card all the time, e.g. when logging on to Windows after returning to the workplace.

Smart card won't be forgotten(error)(tick)The card can always remain in the AirID, which is carried with a clip, yoyo or in the pocket.
No increased premature card failure

(error)

(tick)

Kein vorzeitiger Ausfall der Karte durch Verschleiß der Chip-Kontakte durch ständiges Ein- und Ausstecken, da sie immer im AirID verbleibt

No increased failure of the card due to deterioration of the chip caontacts caused by constant inserting and removingNo premature card failure due to increased wear of the chip contacts caused by constant insertion and removal, as it always remains in the AirID.

Connectivity
Wired via USB(tick)(tick)
Wireless via Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE)(error)(tick)
Security
Automatic log off when leaving the work stationworkstation

(error)

(tick)

The distance can be set individually by the user via on the AirID.
Secure communication

(tick)

(wired)

(tick)

(wireless AES256 encrypted)

Wireless Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) communication is seured by additional AES256 encryption.
Made in Germany

(warning)

(depending on manufacturer)

(tick)

...